Crypto and DeFi risks are not only questions for financial institutions and regulators. They also offer a broader lesson for technical decision-makers: innovation can create real value, but complexity and rapid growth can make it difficult to see where risk is accumulating. The experience of the 2008 financial crisis provides a useful framework for assessing whether new financial technologies are solving meaningful problems or simply adding layers of activity and exposure.
In remarks delivered in 2021, then Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu drew parallels between the growth of crypto and decentralized finance (DeFi) and the development of credit derivatives before the crisis. His argument was not that the technologies are identical. Rather, he highlighted recurring patterns: promising ideas can lose their original purpose, concerns can go unchallenged, and opaque sources of profit can obscure who ultimately bears the risk.
Crypto and DeFi risks through the lens of past innovation
Credit default swaps emerged to address a specific challenge: banks had limited ways to hedge the risk that a borrower would default. The ability to transfer credit risk offered potential benefits, including more effective risk management and the capacity to lend. Over time, however, financial engineering expanded into increasingly complex products. Some were promoted as ways to generate higher returns while taking less risk, despite structures that could be difficult to understand.
Hsu saw a comparable tension in the digital asset sector. Blockchain and distributed ledger technologies are often presented as tools for making financial services more accessible, transparent, or independent of traditional intermediaries. Bitcoin’s original design, for example, described peer-to-peer transactions without a trusted third party. These goals are distinct from the many products and activities that later developed around crypto markets.
The practical question is whether a particular innovation delivers on a clear purpose. A technology’s novelty, technical sophistication, or popularity does not by itself establish its value. For financial products, that means examining the problem being solved, who benefits, and whether the product’s design and risks are understandable to its users.
When innovation loses sight of its purpose
One of the central warnings from the pre-2008 period is that useful innovation can become detached from its original objective. Hsu described complex structured products that combined existing exposures and financial instruments in ways that were difficult to assess. In some cases, the pursuit of yield and fees became more prominent than the original aim of improving risk management.
He raised a similar concern about crypto products marketed for returns, including stablecoin accounts and DeFi activities such as staking, yield farming, and liquidity mining. The key issue is not simply that returns are offered. It is whether users can get a clear explanation of where those returns come from, what risks are involved, and how losses could occur. If answers quickly disappear into specialized terminology, it becomes harder for customers, supervisors, and business leaders to evaluate the exposure.
This distinction matters for anyone responsible for assessing a technical or financial system. A feature may work as designed while still creating risks elsewhere in the system. Understanding the complete flow of funds and obligations is essential; a product label or stated purpose is not a substitute for examining how it operates.
Why transparency and scrutiny matter
Hsu also pointed to “social silence” around derivatives before the crisis. Complex language and the promise of financial benefits could discourage difficult questions. When only a small group can explain a system, other participants may defer to apparent expertise rather than test its assumptions.
Crypto and DeFi raise questions that warrant open discussion, including how blockchain governance works, what responsibilities developers or other participants may have, and how trading practices should be understood. Terms such as “trustless” and “immutable” can also create misleading expectations if they are treated as complete descriptions of systems that still depend on technical and governance choices.
For organizations evaluating emerging technology, constructive challenge is part of sound oversight. Questions about failure modes, decision rights, dependencies, and accountability can slow adoption, but they can also reveal weaknesses before those weaknesses become harder to address.
Follow the money to understand exposure
A basic discipline in financial risk management is being able to explain how money is made and lost. Hsu observed that, in trading failures he had seen, the ability to explain profits and losses had broken down at some point. When a business model cannot be described plainly, it is difficult to assess what could go wrong or who would absorb the impact.
That principle applies directly to crypto and DeFi products. Decision-makers should seek clear answers to questions such as:
- What activity generates the stated return?
- What counterparties, assets, or mechanisms are involved?
- What could disrupt the flow of funds or undermine confidence?
- Who bears losses if an assumption, service, or market mechanism fails?
Stablecoin runs are one potential source of disruption identified by Hsu. He also noted that events such as hacks, protocol exploits, abrupt changes in a blockchain, or other failures could erode trust. A system may withstand individual incidents, but that does not establish how it would respond as its user base grows and includes participants with different expectations of safety.
Three lessons for responsible innovation
The historical comparison suggests three practical principles for those building, adopting, or overseeing financial technology:
- Anchor innovation in purpose. Define the problem and explain why solving it matters. Assess the outcome, not just the novelty of the technology.
- Make room for skeptics. Encourage informed debate about assumptions, governance, consumer impacts, and possible failure scenarios.
- Follow the money. Require a straightforward account of how value is created, where exposure sits, and how losses could occur.
Hsu specifically questioned whether the crypto and DeFi activity of the time was advancing financial inclusion in practice. Stating an inclusion goal is not enough; it should be possible to explain how a product improves access to services such as payments, banking, or credit and what risks users face.
Conclusion: preserve the value, manage the risks
The history of credit derivatives does not determine the future of blockchain or digital assets. It does show why promising technology needs clear objectives, open scrutiny, and transparent economics. For technical decision-makers and financial organizations, the practical task is to look beyond claims of efficiency or disruption and examine system behavior, incentives, governance, and potential loss pathways. Those disciplines can help distinguish durable innovation from complexity that is difficult to justify or supervise.
Access Official Technical PDF