Energy system interoperability is a practical requirement when assets, control platforms and services from different vendors must exchange information reliably. This need becomes more pronounced as power systems coordinate a wider mix of generation resources, including variable renewable sources. A structured workflow developed for the energy domain offers a way to turn operational needs into shared specificationsâand then test whether independent implementations work together.
The approach, applied by the Integrating the Energy System (IES) Austria project, adapts a methodology established in medical IT. Its central premise is that interoperability cannot be assured by specifications alone. Use cases, technical profiles and hands-on testing need to work as parts of an iterative process.
Why energy system interoperability needs a defined process
Smart energy systems are made up of connected components that may be developed and operated independently. A virtual power plant (VPP), for example, coordinates assets with an operator and interacts with established grid-control mechanisms. These components need to exchange information in ways that support the wider business operation.
When vendors interpret an interface specification differently, systems can implement the same stated requirements in incompatible ways. A vendorâs internal conformance test may confirm that its product follows its own interpretation, but it does not establish that another vendorâs system can communicate with it. Peer-to-peer interoperability testing addresses this gap by testing systems together.
A shared process can also support vendor-neutral integration: participants agree on the problem to solve, define the required exchanges, test implementations and refine the specification based on observed issues.
Four steps from operational need to tested integration
The IES workflow organizes interoperability work into four connected steps:
- Identify use cases. Describe where systems need to interact, define the system boundaries and capture the relevant requirements.
- Develop integration profiles. Specify agreed technical solutions for addressing the interoperability issues identified in the use cases. These profiles define how participating systems should exchange information.
- Test independent implementations. Bring systems from different vendors together in a plugfest or Connectathon, where teams can test exchanges, identify problems and improve the profiles.
- Publish successful testing activity. Record which participants tested successfully and which products implement the relevant profiles.
Integration profiles are treated as evolving documents rather than fixed specifications from the outset. Feedback from implementation and testing helps clarify requirements and improve the profile until it becomes more stable. This makes the process both technical and collaborative: users and vendors contribute as peers, while committees coordinate work and decisions.
How profiles connect business cases to technical exchanges
A Technical Framework organizes the material for a particular business case and domain. Its informative section describes the business case and the functions derived from use cases. Its normative section contains the integration profiles: the specified message exchanges, known as transactions, and the actorsâsoftware modulesâthat perform them.
This structure gives engineers and integrators a path from an operational requirement to a defined system interaction. Planning and technical committees support that path by assigning profiles to frameworks, deciding when profiles are ready for testing and developing test scenarios and tools. Domain coordination can also help identify where existing profiles may be reused across areas.
What peer testing adds beyond conformance checks
In 2018, the first peer-to-peer energy testing sessions were held at Connectathon Europe in The Hague. Systems from four vendors took part in tests based on IEC 61850 communication between a client and a server. The exchanges represented VPP-related examples, including sending configuration data from assets to an operator, sending schedules from the operator to assets and retrieving measurement values from assets.
The event tested both the trial integration profiles and the use of the Gazelle testbed in the energy domain. Gazelle supports test-case and system management, documentation and validation. In the described setup, a proxy captured messages exchanged between systems under test and forwarded them for validation.
Gazelleâs validation approach included checking whether XML messages were well formed, whether they conformed to an XML schema and whether specified business rules were met using Schematron validation. Captured messages gave participants material to review when an exchange did not meet expectations. A dedicated test network and a VPN connection were used to link the test setup in The Hague with the Gazelle installation in Vienna.
Lessons for engineering teams and system integrators
The initial trial demonstrated that the methodology and testbed could be applied to smart energy systems, while also highlighting the need for continued refinement. Participants found that requirements and validation assertions needed to be more restrictive in some areas. The project also identified the value of using Gazelle for pre-event testing so teams could check message content before meeting for peer testing.
For engineering organizations, the workflow points to several useful practices:
- Start with specific operational use cases and clearly defined system boundaries.
- Write integration requirements precisely enough to limit conflicting interpretations.
- Test exchanges between independent implementations, not only within a single vendorâs environment.
- Use findings from captured and validated messages to improve profiles and test cases.
- Run available pre-testing before a shared interoperability event.
Conclusion
Reliable energy system interoperability depends on more than choosing a communications standard. Teams also need shared, testable definitions of how systems use that standard in specific operational scenarios. By linking use cases, integration profiles, peer testing and iterative refinement, the IES workflow provides a structured way to validate exchanges between independent systems. For plant, grid and automation stakeholders, the practical lesson is to treat interoperability as a lifecycle activity: define the interaction, test it with other implementations and use the results to make the specification clearer and more dependable.
Access Official Technical PDF