📘 Resource Overview & Documentation Details

You are viewing the technical directory listing for Collaborative Robot Safety: Understanding Pain Thresholds. This engineering resource is curated under our Collaborative Robots division to support automation specialists, control systems engineers, and manufacturing technicians looking for verified reference materials.

🔍 Contextual Abstract & Technical Scope

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

As collaborative robots work closer to people, collision safety becomes a practical design and integration concern. Pressure pain threshold data can help inform collaborative robot safety assessments, but the measurements are not universal limits: they vary with the body site and individual characteristics. A study of 90 healthy adult men measured thresholds at 15 locations, illustrating both the value and the limits of using pain as a reference for potential human-robot contact.

Why pressure pain thresholds matter in robot safety

Traditional industrial robots have often operated in separated workspaces, while collaborative robots are intended to share tasks and space with people. In those settings, contact may occur through impact, clamping, squeezing, or other forms of pressure. Understanding the human response to pressure is therefore relevant to risk assessment and protective measures.

Determining an injury threshold experimentally presents practical and ethical challenges. The study describes the rationale for using pain thresholds in the development of collaborative robot safety guidance: pain is expected to occur below the threshold for mild injury, so it can serve as a conservative reference point. That rationale does not mean that pressure below a measured pain threshold guarantees the absence of injury in every situation. The measurements characterize reported pain under specific test conditions; they do not define a complete safety limit for every robot, person, or collision.

The research was conducted in the context of ISO/TS 15066, which addresses collaborative industrial robot applications. Its central engineering implication is that contact conditions matter. A single pressure value may not adequately reflect the range of human responses across body regions and individuals.

How the study measured human-robot contact thresholds

Researchers tested 90 healthy Korean men aged 20 to 50. A custom pressure-induction system used a moving contactor, force and pressure sensors, and a control program. The contactor advanced toward the skin at 1 mm per second. Participants indicated when pressure reached their defined pain threshold, corresponding to a visual analog scale rating of 4–5. Each of 15 body sites was measured three times, with rest periods between sites.

The tested locations included the forehead, neck, shoulder, spine, chest, abdomen, arm, hand, thigh, shin, and calf. Measurements were taken on the non-dominant side. A trained operator conducted the tests, and the equipment was checked using a test dummy before participant measurements. These details are important when interpreting the results: the findings came from controlled, static pressure tests, not from a broad range of dynamic robot collisions.

Thresholds varied substantially by body site

Average pressure pain thresholds differed across the tested locations. The lowest reported mean was at the arm nerve site, at approximately 65 N/cm²; the highest was at the back of the hand, at approximately 196 N/cm². Relatively low thresholds were also found at several joint, muscle, and nerve locations. Moderate values, around 100–120 N/cm², were reported at the forehead, neck muscle, and ball of the thumb. The shin and other sites showed their own distinct results.

Variation was not limited to differences between body sites. Thresholds also varied widely among participants at the same site. For engineers and integrators, this spread is a key consideration: average values alone do not describe the full range of responses. The study’s results support treating the location and nature of possible contact as part of a risk assessment, rather than assuming that one pressure threshold applies uniformly to the body.

Age and BMI findings require careful interpretation

Participants younger than 30 generally had lower measured thresholds than those older than 30. The size of the difference depended on the site: it was largest at the C7 spinal area, shoulder joint, and neck muscle, while differences at the forehead and hand sites were small. This pattern suggests age may be relevant when considering population variability, but the study does not establish a threshold for every age group.

Results by body mass index (BMI) were less consistent. The higher-BMI group had higher or similar thresholds at many locations, with differences at some sites, including the shoulder and neck. However, the regression analysis found no statistically significant association between BMI and threshold. BMI should therefore not be treated as a reliable stand-alone predictor of an individual’s response based on these findings.

What the findings mean for collaborative robot safety

The study offers useful human-response data, but its scope matters when applying it to industrial systems. Participants were all men, within a defined age range, and measurements were made under controlled static pressure. The findings do not directly establish safe force or pressure limits for every operating condition, nor do they capture every factor that can shape a real collision.

In practical assessments, teams can use the evidence to support questions such as:

  • Which body regions could be exposed to contact during normal operation or foreseeable interaction?
  • Could the application create pressure, impact, clamping, or squeezing conditions?
  • How do the robot’s configuration and protective measures address the specific contact risks?
  • Are safety decisions relying too heavily on an average value when individual responses vary?

The researchers also observed mild skin changes, including temporary depressions and redness, after pressure testing. No severe damage was reported, and the observed changes generally resolved within minutes to several hours. These observations reinforce the distinction between pain measurements and a comprehensive evaluation of injury risk.

Conclusion: use threshold data as context, not a universal limit

Pressure pain thresholds can inform collaborative robot safety work by showing how strongly human responses depend on contact location and individual differences. In this study, mean values ranged from roughly 65 to 196 N/cm² across 15 body sites, with age-related differences at several locations and no consistent, significant BMI relationship. For plant teams, system integrators, and robot manufacturers, the practical takeaway is to consider the intended application, possible contact regions, and relevant protective measures together. Pain-threshold data provide important context for risk assessment, but should not be interpreted in isolation as a guarantee of safe contact.

Access Official Technical PDF